Mystery Tackle Box – D2C Ranking & Growth Metrics
Monthly subscription boxes of fishing tackle, sorted by species and skill level.
Last updated · November 2026 edition · data to end of October 2026 · method v1.3
Mystery Tackle Box fell 32 places this month to #493 of 903, and is #81 of 188 in Sports & Outdoor. On our estimate its revenue is shrinking year on year (high confidence). Branded search is declining over the past year, with a seasonal peak in November and December. Its closest competitor is AFTCO (#390).
revenue (est.) Whether we estimate the brand's revenue is growing, flat or shrinking compared with a year earlier, from the online signals most tied to sales: branded search and site traffic, weighted towards the last three months.
It is a direction of travel, not a figure. We can't see prices, conversion, or sales through retailers and Amazon, so confidence is lower for brands that sell mostly through stockists, or when the signals disagree; with low confidence we only call growth or decline on a big move.
How scoring works →Year on year, high confidence; close to flat. Why
scale A 0–100 score built from branded search (35%), site traffic (35%) and social following (30%).
It uses a log scale, so a brand 10 times bigger scores roughly 30 points higher. Higher means bigger.
How scoring works →How big Mystery Tackle Box is today: #493 of 903 by size.
momentum Year-on-year growth in branded search, site traffic and social, over the last 12 months and the last 3 months.
50 means flat. Above 50 is growing (a brand that doubled scores about 88); below 50 is shrinking (halved scores about 12).
Scale is size, Momentum is direction: a small brand can grow fast, and a big one can be shrinking.
How scoring works →How fast it's growing: declining (50 = flat).
what drives the score where Mystery Tackle Box sits all 903 brands sports & outdoor (188) Scale, 0 to 100 on a log scale: every 10× in size adds the same points. Mystery Tackle Box is #493 of 903 by size.
Is Mystery Tackle Box's revenue growing?
We estimate Mystery Tackle Box's revenue is shrinking year on year (high confidence). Branded search and site traffic don't contradict each other, so confidence is high.
Estimated from year-on-year changes in branded search and site traffic. A direction of travel, not a revenue figure: we can't see prices, conversion, or retail and Amazon sales. How we estimate it.
How fast is Mystery Tackle Box growing?
Mystery Tackle Box's Momentum score is 42.1, which means it is declining (50 means flat; a brand that doubled would score about 88). Branded search is declining over the past 12 months, and declining sharply over the last three months compared with the same months a year earlier. Site traffic is growing over the same 12 months. Since August 2026 it has moved from #404 to #493 overall. Its size score is driven most by social audience, with site traffic relatively weakest.
About Mystery Tackle Box
Mystery Tackle Box ships monthly boxes of fishing tackle, sorted by species and tier: Regular, Pro and Elite plans each pack a set number of baits, with anglers able to pick bass, panfish, trout, inshore saltwater or walleye gear and switch species at any time. Beyond the subscription, the brand sells one-off tackle kits, bundles, bags and slings, plus apparel such as t-shirts and hoodies. Seasonal items like a 12 Days of Fishmas advent calendar and a tackle-loaded soft cooler round out the catalogue.
Mystery Tackle Box competitors
Brands that sell the same kind of product as Mystery Tackle Box, closest match first. See every brand in Sports & Outdoor or the full D2C brand rankings.
Fishing apparel, gaffs, fighting belts and tackle for offshore and freshwater anglers.
Bass fishing baits, rods, tackle and apparel built around named signature lures
Fly and sea fishing tackle designed in Plymouth since 1978
Soft and hard fishing lures, rods and tackle for predator anglers.
Fishing lures and tackle, from hollow body frogs to ice fishing baits
Mystery Tackle Box vs AFTCO
AFTCO leads on both size and growth: Scale 47.5 against 43.5, and Momentum 42 against 42. See AFTCO's page.
| November 2026 | Mystery Tackle Box | AFTCO |
|---|---|---|
| Overall rank | #493 | #390 |
| Sports & Outdoor rank | #81 | #65 |
| Scale (size) | 43.5 | 47.5 |
| Momentum (growth) | 42.1 | 42.3 |
| Branded search | 34 | 41 |
| Site traffic | 26 | 39 |
| Social audience | 75 | 64 |
Scores run 0 to 100. Signal scores show what drives each brand's Scale. The higher value in each row is in bold.
Mystery Tackle Box branded search volume
How often people search for Mystery Tackle Box by name, month by month, indexed so the peak month = 100 (we publish the trend, not raw vendor figures). Over the past year, demand is declining; the last three months, compared with the same months a year earlier, are declining sharply. Demand is seasonal, peaking in November and December and lowest in February.
Mystery Tackle Box's audience, products and channels
Social audience
- Instagram mysterytacklebox 737k
- YouTube MysteryTackleBox 270k
Also on X and Facebook.
Followers as shown on each platform, collected for the November 2026 edition.
Products
- Products in store149
- New in the last 90 days43
- Typical price25
- Price range4 – 450
From Mystery Tackle Box's own online store.
Where it sells
- Own online storeyes
- Retailers / stockistsyes
- Amazonnot found
Its site is most visited in Canada and the US.
Mystery Tackle Box: common questions
What does Mystery Tackle Box sell?
Monthly subscription boxes of fishing tackle, sorted by species and skill level.
Where is Mystery Tackle Box from?
Mystery Tackle Box is based in United States.
Where can you buy Mystery Tackle Box?
Mystery Tackle Box sells through its own online store and selected retailers. Its online store is at mysterytacklebox.com.
Is Mystery Tackle Box's revenue growing?
Our estimate is shrinking year on year, with high confidence. It is a direction from online signals, not a sales figure.
Who are Mystery Tackle Box's competitors?
The brands closest to Mystery Tackle Box in what they sell are AFTCO, Googan Squad, Snowbee and Svartzonker.
Scale and signal scores run from 0 to 100 on a fixed log scale; Momentum is 50 when flat. November 2026, method v1.3. See the methodology, or report a correction. Want to hear when Mystery Tackle Box moves? Follow Mystery Tackle Box.